The tragic event of 9/11 has prompted questions,
devastation, and loss of loved ones to this country. Jon Updike and Susan
Sontag wrote essays that were in the New Yorker's "Talk of the Town,” each having his/her own
perspective on what occurred that particular day.
Jon Updike's essay was both honest and truthful. I
liked his piece since he described what was happening all around him, on top of
an apartment building. He was able to see the destruction first hand with
"smoked speckled bits of paper curling into the cloudless sky," the
horrifying sight of the "south tower dropping," while holding onto
his wife realizing he just watched thousands of people die. The author
states that this tragic event had a "false intimacy of
Television," that the newscasters could not capture the emotions and
"horrendous" event. Updike referred to as a "nightmare
ballet," scenes being replayed over and over. Many, like Updike, didn't-(couldn't)
believe this could happen, that it "was not quite
real."
Not only that, but Updike has a positive outlook on
the whole situation. Through this hard time on many, everyone worked together
to “pick up the pieces” and continue onward, “to go on living.” Updike has this
amazing attitude on the aftermath. He makes a connection with the motto, “the
sun will rise tomorrow” by saying hey, we can get back to normal. The “boats
tentatively move in the river, the ruins still sending out smoke, but New York
looked glorious.”
On the other hand, Susan Sontag starts right from
the beginning and was not afraid to speak her mind on the issues that laid at
hand. These issues dealt with the media, the attackers, and how our country as
a whole responded to the situation. Basically she is saying why focus on "cowardly"
attack on "civilization,”
"liberty,” "humanity" or "the free world" but
an attack on the world's self-proclaimed Superpower over ruled by the actions
of the invaders. Sontag
clearly states that government is trying to “protect” the country by saying “everything
is OK” and “our country is strong” when clearly it isn’t. The author brigs up
an interesting point on “who doesn’t think America is strong?” Is the government
just saying that to reassure themselves, or trying to convince other counties
that they are going to move on, pick up the pieces, and “stand tall?” They are
not giving out details of the reality that had been brought forward. The government
should start “thinking more” and making smart
decisions to put our country back onto its feet. To do so, “America doesn’t
just need to be strong.”
Even though I was five at the time of 9/11, I remember what happened, at least to my mom. I was on a play-date with one of my good friends and I just remember playing in the yard when my mom ran inside. I followed her and she said to go back outside so I did. Not until recently, a few years ago, did I find that my aunt (mom’s sister) was scheduled to work on one of those plans that crashed into one of the world trade centers. I don't know the exact reason why she didn't work that day, but I remember my dad going to meet her in New Jersey for her to come visit us and made it to our house safely very late the night before September 11th. Every year I like to watch documentaries of this event, just to learn more about what happened. Every person has their own perspective on what happened that day.
Hi Ashley! You have a great perspective on each of these articles. I really appreciated Updike's poetic description. He gave an emotional, human account of the days events that wasnt necessarily conveyed through television. Sontag was right to draw attention to the superficial response of our government. I think the nation was in such shock and despair, the response was adequate. I also enjoy watching the documentaries on the events of that day, because it is important to never forget! Hope you enjoyed your summer! See you soon :)
ReplyDelete